When it comes time to replace your roof or choose a material for a new build, most homeowners in the Branson and Springfield area find themselves torn between two of the most popular roofing options: metal roofing and asphalt shingles. Both have their own sets of advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice often depends on a homeowner’s priorities, durability, budget, aesthetics, maintenance needs, and even how long they plan to stay in the home.
Let’s break down the key differences between these two materials so you can make a fully informed decision.
Cost and Upfront Investment
Asphalt Shingles:
Asphalt shingles continue to dominate the residential roofing market in part because of their affordability. The cost of materials and installation is lower compared to metal. For homeowners working within a tight budget or who need to roof multiple buildings (such as a home and detached garage), asphalt shingles make financial sense.
Average cost in Missouri: $4 to $6 per square foot installed.
Metal Roofing:
Metal roofing comes with a higher upfront cost. This includes both the materials (aluminum, steel, or standing seam panels) and the labor, which often requires more specialized installation. However, when evaluating long-term costs, metal may prove to be more economical due to its lifespan and reduced maintenance.
Average cost in Missouri: $8 to $12 per square foot installed.
Bottom line: If your primary concern is the initial price tag, asphalt shingles will cost you less up front. But if you’re looking at roofing as a long-term investment, metal could potentially save you money over time.
Lifespan and Durability
Asphalt Shingles:
Most traditional asphalt shingle roofs last 15 to 30 years, depending on the product grade, local climate, and installation quality. Missouri weather can be unpredictable, and hail or strong winds can easily damage shingles, leading to repairs or premature replacement.
Metal Roofing:
Metal roofs can last 40 to 70 years. They’re highly resistant to wind, rain, snow, and even fire. In fact, metal is often rated to withstand wind gusts up to 140 mph. While dents from large hail are possible (especially with softer metals like aluminum), structural damage is rare.
Bottom line: Metal roofing offers a significantly longer lifespan and better resistance to harsh elements, which can be crucial in storm-prone areas.
Maintenance and Repairs
Asphalt Shingles:
Shingles are easier to install, but they can also be more prone to issues. Over time, you may notice curling, cracking, or granule loss. Missing or damaged shingles are relatively simple to replace, but you may need periodic inspections to catch problems before they become serious.
Metal Roofing:
Metal is incredibly low-maintenance. Most problems, if they occur, stem from poor installation, such as improperly secured fasteners or flashing. When installed correctly, metal roofing rarely requires much attention. Snow and debris typically slide off with ease, reducing the risk of buildup.
Bottom line: Asphalt roofs may need more ongoing upkeep, while metal roofs typically require fewer repairs over their lifetime.
Energy Efficiency
Asphalt Shingles:
Standard asphalt shingles tend to absorb heat, which can raise attic temperatures in the summer. There are cool roof variants available that reflect more sunlight, but they often come at a premium.
Metal Roofing:
Metal naturally reflects solar radiant heat, especially when paired with reflective coatings. This can reduce cooling costs significantly during the hot and humid Ozark summers. In some cases, homeowners report energy savings of up to 25%.
Bottom line: For energy-conscious homeowners, metal roofing offers a clear edge.
Aesthetic and Curb Appeal
Asphalt Shingles:
Modern shingles come in a wide range of colors and styles, including some that mimic the appearance of wood shake or slate. They fit well with many traditional home styles and HOAs often prefer them.
Metal Roofing:
Once limited to barns and commercial buildings, today’s metal roofing can look incredibly sharp. It comes in panels, shingles, and tiles, and it’s available in various finishes and colors. Whether you’re going for a rustic farmhouse vibe or something more modern, metal can deliver. However, it may not always align with neighborhood design standards or personal taste.
Bottom line: Asphalt shingles are more common and widely accepted; metal roofing offers a bold, distinctive look.
Environmental Impact
Asphalt Shingles:
Most asphalt shingles are petroleum-based and not easily recyclable. After removal, they often end up in landfills. Their production also uses more fossil fuels.
Metal Roofing:
Metal is one of the most eco-friendly roofing options. It’s usually made from recycled materials and is fully recyclable at the end of its life. Its reflective properties also help reduce the urban heat island effect in densely populated areas.
Bottom line: If sustainability matters to you, metal is the greener choice.
Noise and Insulation
Asphalt Shingles:
Asphalt naturally dampens sound, making it the quieter of the two options during rain or hailstorms.
Metal Roofing:
Metal roofs can be louder in heavy rain or hail, especially without proper insulation. However, many modern installations include solid sheathing and sound-deadening underlayment to mitigate this.
Bottom line: If outside noise is a concern, asphalt has a slight advantage, unless your metal roof is well-insulated.
Installation Time and Labor
Asphalt Shingles:
Installing asphalt shingles is faster and requires fewer specialized skills. This can be advantageous if you’re trying to meet a tight construction timeline or fix storm damage quickly.
Metal Roofing:
Installation of metal roofing takes more time and expertise. Improper installation can lead to major issues, so it’s crucial to work with experienced contractors familiar with the material.
Bottom line: Asphalt is quicker and easier to install; metal requires skilled labor and careful attention.
So... Which One Should You Choose?
Here’s a quick recap to help you decide:
| Factor | Asphalt Shingles | Metal Roofing |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Cost | Lower | Higher |
| Lifespan | 15–30 years | 40–70 years |
| Durability | Moderate | High |
| Maintenance | Moderate | Low |
| Energy Efficiency | Low–Moderate | High |
| Appearance | Traditional | Modern/Varied |
| Environmental Impact | Less eco-friendly | Highly sustainable |
| Noise Reduction | Better | Needs insulation |
| Installation | Easier/Faster | Slower/Skilled labor |
Final Thoughts from Branson Springfield Roof Co.
There’s no universal “best” roofing material, only what works best for your needs, budget, and preferences. If you’re looking for affordability and a classic look, asphalt shingles are likely the right pick. If long-term value, energy savings, and durability are priorities, metal roofing is worth the investment.
At Branson Springfield Roof Co., we install both asphalt and metal roofing, and we’re happy to walk you through your options based on your home’s unique situation. Our team brings years of experience working in the Ozarks region, where weather can shift fast and roofing needs to stand up to the challenge.
Ready to explore your roofing options? Give us a call or schedule a consultation today.